International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 4, Issue 2, February-2013 1
ISSN 2229-5518
Review and Analysis of Microstrip Patch Array
Antenna with different configurations
Kuldeep Kumar Singh, Dr. S.C.Gupta
Abstract - Microstrip patch antenna in wireless communication is gaining importance as a most powerful technological trend. Its immense potential promises significant change in near term future of wireless application fields. Current technological trend has focused much more attention towards microstrip patch antenna. Single microstrip patch antenna has some advantages (low cost, light weight, conformal & low profile), but it has little disadvantages too- like low gain, low efficiency, low directivity and narrow bandwidth. These disadvantages can be overcome by implementation of many patch antennas in array configuration. Here term array stands for geometrical and electrical arrangements of patch elements. As we increase number of patch elements to form an array, improvement in performance is observed. In this review paper, performance characteristics for 2, 4, 8, 16 patch elements configured in 2x1, 2x2, 8x1 and 4x4 (respectively) array format has been analyzed and compared.
Index Terms- Microstrip Patch antenna, Array, Feed Mechanism, Impedance Matching, Return Loss, Radiation Patterns, Gain, Directivity and
Bandwidth.
- - - - - - - - - - ♦ - - - - - - - - - -
1. INTRODUCTION
Microstrip patch antenna is a single layer design which contains mainly these four parts - Patch, Ground plane, Substrate and Feeding part. It is very simple in construction using conventional microstrip line feed. Patch can be given any shape but rectangular and circular configurations are mostly used. Ground Plane can be finite or infinite according to model (Transmission line - model, cavity model, full wave Model or method of moments) used for analysis of dimensions [1-4].
Relative Permittivity and height are two important characteristics for substrate, Feeding Part can be implemented in these ways - Microstrip line, coaxial probe, Aperture coupled and Proximity coupled Feed [5].
An Antenna is an essential component in Radio communication system that is needed in both transmitting and receiving terminals. Each type of antenna is good in its own way with different uses and properties. Microstrip patch antenna array is set of two or more patch elements. Signals from the individual patch elements are processed-
Kuldeep Kumar Singh is pursuing M.Tech in Digital communication from
Dehradun Institute of Technology, Dehradun, Uttarakhand, (India).
.Email: kuldeep_singh_vns@yahoo.com
Dr. S.C.Gupta is Professor in Department of Electronics and communication at Dehradun Institute of Technology, Dehradun, Uttarakhand, (India).
Email : sureshprem1938@gmail.com
in order to achieve improved performance over single antenna. To obtain highly directive Patterns, it is required that fields from elements of array are added positively in desired direction and cancel each other in other directions [6].
When the patch is excited by the Feed mechanism, charges are accumulated at edge of the patch. These charges create fringing fields and these fringing fields at edge of microstrip antenna add up in phase and produce radiation of the microstrip antenna [7-8].
2. MICROSTRIP PATCH AND OPERATION
Microstrip antenna is also known as Patch antenna. Fig.1 shows structure of patch antenna with 3 axes X, Y, Z. it has
3 layers: top layer is the Patch, middle layer is substrate
(with suitable height and dielectric constant), and bottom layer is the ground.
Fig.1 Microstrip patch antenna.
IJSER © 2013 http://www.ijser.org
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 4, Issue 2, February-2013 2
ISSN 2229-5518
Three essential parameters for operation of microstrip patch antenna are : frequency of operation (resonance frequency), relative permittivity (dielectric constant) of substrate, height of substrate (h).after these three parameters length, width, input impedance of the patch and fed dimensions are evaluated. Then performance of antenna i.e. Radiation pattern, S parameter, Efficiency and Reflected loss is obtained by simulating it on software [9-
14].
3. PATCH ARRAY ANALYSIS
3.1. Design and analysis of 2x1 Array
Here 2x1 (2 elements) Array configuration has been designed & analyzed at 2.4 GHz for wireless application field.
Rectangular microstrip Patch antenna has been taken here for 2x1 Array arrangements. Resonance frequency (f0)=2.4
GHz, Relative Dielectric constant (Єr)=2.2 and height of
substrate (h) is 1.588 mm.
Dimensions for single patch Element are shown below [6].
The width of the patch W = 49.41069.
Effective Dielectric Constant of the patch = 2.11106.
Extension of the patch length, ΔL of the patch = 0 .2885
mm.
Actual length of the patch, L = 41.35621 mm.
The value of the y0 = 10.457 mm.
Input impedance of the patch Z in = 204 Ω.
Above dimension is used for both elements in the array. Formation of an array requires feeding arrangement with proper impedance matched network (as shown in fig.3) Inset Fed has been used here, dimensions for feeding line are: width (w1) of 50 ohm impedance line is 4.8125 mm and of 100 ohm (w2) is 1.4079 mm.
Fig.2 design for 2x1 arrays [9].
After simulating this 2x1 array on software S-parameter & Radiation patterns are obtained which are shown in fig.3 and Fig.4.
Fig.3 S Parameter for 2x1 arrays [9].
Fig.4 Radiation Pattern for 2x1 arrays [9].
As we see from above graphs Return loss achieved is -9.5 dB and obtained Gain is 9.186 dB.
3.2. Design and analysis of 2x2 Array
A multi element microstrip patch antenna array applicable to WLAN/MIMO has been designed here which operates at
2.45 GHz frequency band [10].
Fig.5 Geometry of 2x2 arrays with feed point [13].
IJSER © 2013 http://www.ijser.org
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 4, Issue 2, February-2013 3
ISSN 2229-5518
Geometrical arrangement of 2x2 arrays (4 elements) is shown in Figure 9. Dimensions of Patch element is taken as: length (L) = 24.6 mm, width (W) = 19.8 mm, Resonance frequency = 2.45 GHz, relative permittivity=10, h=1.5875. Distance between antenna element is set at 6.2 cm. antenna is fed by 50 ohms coaxial probe through a connector [10].
Fig.6 Return loss for 2x2 array [10].
Fig.7 E-plane & H plane for 2x2 array [10].
Fig.8 Total field gain vs. frequency for 2x2 array [10].
Fig.(6, 7 & 8) shows Return loss, Radiation pattern and total field gain for 2x2 Array.
With proposed 2x2 array 11.80 dbi peak gains is achieved. Simulation gives 25.24 db band-widths centered at 2.4546
GHz for VSWR lower than 1.5. Antenna array shows good
radiation efficiency at WLAN band (2.40-2.48 GHz [10].
3.3. Design and analysis of 8x1 arrays
An array with 8 elements configured in an 8x1 is designed here. With this large antenna array narrow beams are obtained which are applicable for direction accuracy in wind profiling Radars [11].
Here an 8x1 linear array (8 elements) has been designed. First step in design is to specify dimensions for single patch; here single patch taken is square patch. Dimensions for this square patch are: operating frequency=1.28 GHz, relative dielectric constant (Єr) is 2.2, height of substrate (h)=3.175 mm, w=7.6 cm and a=9.5 cm [11].When inter- element distance is selected to be 0.73λ, 8x1 arrays satisfies initial design requirements (Beamwidth = 9 degree & operating frequency=1.28 GHz).
Fig. 9 Square patch element used for 8x1 arrays [11].
With all above shown specifications an 8x1 Array is formed and simulated on software, after simulation obtained results are shown in fig.11 & Fig.12. Fig.11 shows total field gain obtained at 1.28 GHz frequency and fig.12 shows radiation patterns obtained (E plane & H plane).
Fig.12 (a) shows E field at 1.28 GHz for 8x1 arrays with phi=0 degree and Fig.12 (b) shows E field at 1.28 GHz for
8x1 arrays with phi=90 degree.
IJSER © 2013 http://www.ijser.org
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 4, Issue 2, February-2013 4
ISSN 2229-5518
An 8x1 array has been designed; maximum gain reaches to
16.75 dbi at 1.28 GHz (Fig.11), antenna exhibits 20 MHz bandwidth and beam-width achieved is 9 degree [11].
Fig. 10 an 8x1 array formed with square patch [11].
(b)
Fig.12 (a) and (b) shows radiation pattern of 8x1 arrays that operate at
1.28 GHz [11].
3.4. Design and analysis of 4x4 Array
Fig.11 Gain vs. frequency for 8x1 arrays.
(a)
4x4 (16 patch elements) microstrip patch antenna array is designed with operating frequency at 5.8 GHz for point to point communication. WLAN Point to Point application is based on IEEE 802.11a standard and operates in upper unlicensed national information infrastructure band [12].
Fig.13 shows configuration of 4x4 patch antenna array. Dimension for single patch is 15.5 mm x11.5 mm, with inset feed at 4.3 mm; width of transmission line is 3 mm. A co- axial feed is connected to center of array from other side of substrate. Quarter wave transformer impedance matching and power divider section is used to provide power to each element of the array. Here for 50 ohms input line a 3 db power divider can be made using two 100 ohms lines [12].
Fig.13 4x4 Patch antenna array [12]
IJSER © 2013 http://www.ijser.org
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 4, Issue 2, February-2013 5
ISSN 2229-5518
array of microstrip antenna with inset feed has been designed and return loss of the antenna array is within designed frequency band [12].
4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION [9-12]
Fig.14 Return loss for simulation and fabrication of 4x4 array [12].
Table 1 shows obtained output from 2x1, 2x2, 8x1 and 4x4
Arrays [9-12].
(a)
(b)
Fig.15 a) E-plane b) H-plane [12].
Simulation result gives a return loss of -43 db at 5.88 GHz, Bandwidth achieved is 15%. Half power beam-width obtained from E-plane and H-plane radiation pattern is 8.92 degree & 9.33 degree respectively. Gain obtained from E-
plane and H-plane radiation pattern is 16.071 db. Thus 4*4
If we are increasing number of patch elements in the array Gain is enhanced so directivity will also be improved.
Return loss up to -43 dB has been achieved with 16
elements in 4x4 arrays.
Element spacing is nearer in 4x4 arrays as compared to
2x1, 2x2 and 8x1 array, so mutual coupling loss is more in 4x4 Arrays.
Proper impedance matching is required for feeding
network arrangement. If we are using large number of patch elements in array then we will be needed more calculations for length & width of impedance line. So complexion increases for feed network with increase in number of patch elements in arrays.
Power consumption is more in 4x4 arrays as compared
to smaller arrays( 2x1(2 elements), 2x2(4 elements),
8x1(8 elements).
5. CONCLUSION
Microstrip Patch antenna configured in an array format with different number of patch elements has been analyzed. Larger number of patch antenna elements, better gain of
antenna array is achieved. Return loss up to -43 dB has
IJSER © 2013 http://www.ijser.org
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 4, Issue 2, February-2013 6
ISSN 2229-5518
been achieved by 4x4 arrays at 5.8 GHz. Improved Bandwidth, Directivity and radiated power is also achieved by implementing more number of patch elements in the arrays. Here 2x1, 2x2 and 4x4 patch arrays are inset fed so further analysis work would be done by inserting coaxial feed to these arrays. Due to its small size, light weight and conformal properties, these analyzed microstrip patch antenna arrays are useful for WLAN/MIMO and 3G communication systems.
6. REFERENCES
[1]. Kin-Lu Wong, “Compact and broadband microstrip antennas”, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.2002.
[2]. C.A. Balanis, “antenna theory Analysis and design”
second Edition, John Wiley & sons, Inc.
[3]. R.Garg, P. Bhartia, I. Bahl, A. Itipiboon, “Microstrip antenna design handbook”, Artech House, Boston – London, 2000, pp 12-30, ISBN-0-89006-513-6.
[4]. Thomas A. Milligan, “Modern Antenna Design”, John Wiley & Sons, INC. publication, second Edition , 2005, page 281-297, ISBN-13 978-0-471-45776-3 (cloth),ISBN-
10 0-471-45776-0 (cloth).
[5]. B.Rodney, Microstrips patch antennas, “A designer’s guide”, Waterhouse, 1999.
[6]. Mohammad S. Sharawi, “use of low cost patch antennas in modern wireless technology”, IEEE. July/august 2006.
[7]. P. S. Nakar, “Design of a compact microstrip patch antenna for use in wireless/cellular devices”, Florida state university, pp.20-45, and 2004.
[8]. Ahmed F. Alsager, “Design and analysis of microstrip patch antenna arrays”, university college of Boras,
2011.
[9]. Y.S.H.Khraisat, “Design of 4 elements Rectangular microstrip patch antenna with high gain for 2.4 GHz applications”, Canadian center of science & Education, Modern applied science, Vol. 6, No. 1; January 2012.
[10]. C. k. Ghosh & S.k. Parui, “Design and study of a
2*2 microstrip patch antenna array for WLAN/MIMO
applications”, IEEE. Proc. ELECTRO-2009.
[11]. V.R.Anitha & S.N.Reddy, “Design of an 8x1 Square Microstrip patch antenna array”, I.J.E.E.R., Vol.1, number 1.2005, pp.71-77.
[12]. M.K.A.Rahim, A. Asrokin, M.H.Jamaluddin, M.R.Ahmed, T. Masri & M.Z.A. Abdul Aziz, “Microstrip patch antenna array at 5.8 GHz for point to point communication”, IEEE- proceedings, sept.12-
14,2006.
[13]. E.Suneel, B.Prabhakararao & B.T.P.Madhava, “Comparison of Performance Characterization in 2x2,
3x3 & 4x4 Array Antennas”, I.J.E.R.A. ISSN:2248-9622, vol.1,Issue 4,pp.2091-2095.
[14]. N.A.Wahab, Z.B.Maslan & N.Hamzah, “Microstrip rectangular 4x1 Patch Array Antenna at 2.5 GHz for wimax application”, IEEE computer society, pp.164-
168, 2010.
IJSER © 2013 http://www.ijser.org